Prosecutors are arguing Anthony D'Onofrio fatally shot Lexie Castile, while the defense is arguing she killed herself in West 24th Street apartment.

Lexie N. Castile, 20, was rushed to UPMC Hamot, but died of a gunshot wound to her head. Her fiancé, Anthony D'Onofrio, then 25, would tell a 911 operator that Castile shot herself in the head. The ...

An Erie County jury deliberated over the role of a Glock 17 9mm handgun used in the 2012 death of 20-year-old Lexie Castile Prosecutors argued Anthony D'Onofrio shot Castile, while the defense ...

After more than 12 years, a jury is finally hearing testimony in the trial of a man accused of killing 20-year-old Lexie Castile. Castile was found dead of a gunshot wound to the head in September ...

Prosecutors argued during trial he shot 20-year-old Lexie Castile in 2012, while defense argued the shot was self-inflicted.

Lexie N. Castile, 20, was rushed to UPMC Hamot, but died of a gunshot wound to her head. Her fiancé, Anthony D'Onofrio, then 25, would tell a 911 operator that Castile shot herself in the head.